The Nonprofit Exchange Podcast
Watch the Interview
Listen to the Interview
Leadership Is a Practice, Experience Is the Teacher.
Ian Chisholm is the Co-Founder and Partner of Roy Group, where he helps leaders and organizations build stronger cultures through mentorship, experiential learning, and leadership practice. A respected coach, social entrepreneur, and leadership educator, Ian has worked with senior leaders across sectors and helped pioneer executive education initiatives internationally, including the award-winning Columba 1400 leadership centre in Scotland. He is passionate about helping people lead with purpose, integrity, and impact.
The Interview Summary
Leadership develops through everyday choices—and through what we learn when we pause to reflect on them. In this episode of The Nonprofit Exchange, Hugh Ballou welcomes Ian “Chiz” Chisholm of Roy Group for a conversation about intentional leadership, mentorship, and building cultures where people can make their finest contribution.
Drawing on his experience with the American Management Association, Columba 1400, and senior leadership teams, Ian explains how experience becomes a teacher through three practical questions: What worked well? What was tricky? What will we do differently next time?
Ian explores the balance between intention—what we want to accomplish—and attention—what we notice about ourselves, others, and how we show up. He introduces four leadership practices: reflection, inquiry, pause, and action. His distinction between reflection and pausing offers a useful perspective for busy nonprofit leaders: reflection engages the mind, while pausing creates room to rest, replenish, and choose what comes next.
The conversation also explores how understanding someone differs from agreeing with them, how accountability can protect dignity, and why leadership development becomes stronger when senior teams earn the word “mentor” together. Ian shares the experiences that inspired his book, Quiet Champions: A Way Forward for Mentors in Turbulent Times, and the mentors who helped him navigate his first CEO role.
Listeners will discover practical ways to:
- Turn everyday leadership experiences into learning.
- Balance purposeful action with deeper attention.
- Use pausing to respond thoughtfully under pressure.
- Approach conflict with curiosity.
- Strengthen a culture of mentorship and shared responsibility.
Ian leaves us with a compelling paradox: “You are the most important piece of work you will ever undertake. And it is not about you.”
Learn more about Ian’s work at roygroup.net
The Interview Transcript
Hugh Ballou
Welcome to The Nonprofit Exchange. I’m Hugh Ballou. Leadership is something we practice, the choices we make every day. That’s how we practice leadership with our boards, our teams, our volunteers, and the people we serve. Today, we’re exploring how experience becomes a teacher when we bring intention and reflection to those choices. My guest is Ian Chisholm. He is called Chiz. I’m going to just call you Chiz. He’s of Roy Group. His work focuses on leadership development, mentorship, and organizational culture, helping senior leaders and social impact organizations build high-performing teams and lead with purpose.
His experience includes work with AMA and Columba 1400, and he is the author of Quiet Champions: A Way Forward for Mentors in Turbulent Times. The title for today’s interview is Leadership Is a Practice, Experience Is the Teacher. So, Ian, so glad you’re here today. Tell us, what experience first helped you understand that leadership is a practice and experience is the teacher?
Ian Chisholm
I would have been in my early 20s, Hugh, right out of university. As we were talking about earlier, I did not get into med school, which was the dream. And because I had worked for the American Management Association in the summers, they pulled me down to their Operation Enterprise division, which was all very exciting, being from Saskatchewan, landing a job in New York. The job was not particularly glamorous. It involved a lot of picking up volunteer guest speakers for our programs and setting up rooms. But these folks always needed to have dinner, you know, so many people do every day.
And so there was always an opportunity to have a conversation with folks the night before they would run their seminar in front of a group full of young people. And the last hour of their time with us was always reserved for very off-the-cuff questions from young people to these impressive people. They had big leadership jobs, and they had made a lot of stuff happen. Our faculty was really an A-list of leadership talent. It was in those hours, Hugh, that it didn’t really matter what the content was or what specific challenges this leader or that leader faced.
There were these very human themes that kept coming to the top. And it was very clear to me that these people were practitioners. They weren’t experts on leadership. I don’t think there is such a thing. They were practitioners. They were using everything that they had done to date and kind of folding that into how they attacked whatever challenge was in front of them the next time. And those themes became really important to me. I felt very lucky to be in the back of the room just clocking those themes as they came up over and over and over again.
That drew me right into this industry.
Hugh Ballou
So go deeper in the title of leadership as a practice and experience as the teacher. So our audience would be those people sitting in the trenches, the nonprofit leader, the board member. How does this play out in their normal lives, if there is normal?
Ian Chisholm
There’s a cycle that will be very familiar to your listeners: they throw themselves into situations that are way bigger than them. They find their feet, they establish credibility with other people who are prepared to make it happen. They determine a direction and they move people. And if after that cycle, they can take a little bit of time to reflect and to distill down what they learned about people, about community, about leadership, what will happen is that their practice of leadership will build and build and build.
That’s how leaders learn. We learn most from our own experience. There’s no PowerPoint or book that will ever replace a leader’s long line of experience.
Hugh Ballou
I shared with you before we went live that I’m 80. Most of what I’ve learned is from missteps. Some of the leaders I work with are risk-averse. Really, the things we don’t do well, we try to lower the damage. But how do we reframe that instead of failure to make it a learning experience?
Ian Chisholm
I’m a big believer in leaders using models because a model—maybe it’s not exactly right—gives you a move in the moment that counts. And so when I think about the model that I use the most and my clients use the most, after an important experience, whether something has gone well or hasn’t gone well, the questions are the same: What worked well? What was tricky? What will we do differently next time? To me, as a practitioner of leadership, there’s really not much else. There are aspects of any given moment that worked well.
There are things that were tricky for whatever reason. Most importantly, there’s what we’re going to do differently next time.
Hugh Ballou
Yes, it’s empowering. So you talk about the ratio of attention with an A to intention with an I in leadership. What do you mean and how can a leader recognize an imbalance?
Ian Chisholm
I think we all recognize the imbalance between those two things. We can just ask your listeners how much of their day is about an agenda, outcomes, objectives they have, things they’re trying to kick down the field to make happen, and to-do lists. My guess is almost all. That’s what it means to be a part of this busy world that we’re a part of. It’s about doing stuff. It’s about having a clear intention so we can steer things a certain way. That’s different and it needs to be balanced with our discipline of paying attention.
Just noticing. Being the kind of leader that can notice things internally. What’s my body telling me? What emotions are coming up in this moment? What’s the dialogue in my head? Where is my focus? I’m not going to try to shift it. I just want to notice, in its fullness, what’s going on inside me. And then we can bring that same level of attention, that same discipline of attention to others. What’s going on for them? I wonder what this person’s gift is. I wonder what they need right now.
I wonder what they’re trying to make happen. I wonder what they’re struggling through. To be starting from a place of wondering, not trying to fix anything. And then the real stopper for us is to just pay attention to the way that I’m conducting myself, where everything that’s going on inside meets the rest of the world. A leader needs to just pay attention to the way they’re showing up because it’s the way that we conduct ourselves that steers a story this way or that way. There’s a lot in any given moment to pay attention to.
We need to create, little by little, more and more space for just paying attention and being the kind of leader that does that for people and with people.
Hugh Ballou
If you’re watching this on the livestream, this is The Nonprofit Exchange. Chiz is my guest. He’s got lots of wisdom from many years of doing this work. So, Chiz, part of this, you talk about the pause. We’re in a world where everybody’s busy. We’re busy, our board members are busy. We’re filled with activity and sometimes urgency drives us. So you talk about taking the pause. Elaborate on that. When we pause, we have time to pay attention. So talk about the pause, please.
Ian Chisholm
In the work we do, pausing is one of the four key practices that we like to introduce leaders to. Reflection is one. We can talk about that. Inquiry is one. Leaders have always been those people in the system that can kind of craft a question that changes things. Pausing is most certainly one, and then action. For all of us that are busy all the time, we’ll be relieved to know that action, of course, is one of the disciplines of leadership. Pausing is different from reflection. It’s actually the opposite.
Because reflection is when our mind is absolutely full of the situation that we’re about to step into. Pausing as a leader is about our ability to get to complete emptiness. What are those things in our lives that we can do where we rest and recuperate and replenish the kind of energy that it takes to show up for other people the way that leaders know how to do? For years, I’ve noticed that the very best leaders, the people who are pulling the heaviest sleds of responsibility, have a very clear set of strategies for the way they pause.
The way they treat their mornings, their evenings, when they’re partaking in a meal, the way they treat their holidays, their weekends. It might even be the way they’ve learned how to take a deep breath in between two really thorny agenda items in a board meeting. Leaders absolutely need to have ways of getting to empty, because if you can get to empty, it means that you get to choose what goes back in, and that makes you a very agile character in the system.
Hugh Ballou
Wow, paying attention. It’s a continuum here. We deal with the topic of conflict in the church and the nonprofit, and we shy away from it. That’s part of this, isn’t it? Psychiatrist Murray Bowen, creator of the Bowen Family Systems Theory, talks about how anxiety on the part of the leader is contagious to the whole group. That’s part of the pause and the rest of that routine. So, talk about dealing with conflict and then, you know, we never resolve it, but we learn to manage it because in some sense, conflict is a sign of energy in a group.
How do we manage that, not let it get in our spirit, and turn it into an opportunity to learn, reflect, and benefit from it?
Ian Chisholm
Most of what I have learned about conflict, Hugh, comes from my wife, who’s a mediator. She’s been a mediator for 35 years. One of the things she’s helped me learn is that when there’s anger—like you said, when there’s energy—it exists for a very important reason: to protect, to defend, to fight for something. Even if you’re the party in conflict with another, when anger shows up, it’s a signal that there’s something legitimate this person is fighting for or protecting. The story I love the most, which for me changes the whole thing, is about a bus driver who has a bus full of kids.
The kids are rowdy in the back because they’re kids and he’s had enough. He slams on the brakes. All these kids push into the seat in front of them. He turns around and in a very glowering way tells those kids to sit down and shut up. Not the best manners. Parents are upset. Word of this goes home. There’s parents in the principal’s office, and they want this bus driver dealt with, maybe even fired. This is not the sort of adult that should be with kids. And so, yeah, it was angry.
The way he did that was angry. I wonder why he was angry. Somehow, get underneath whatever it was that he said: ‘I can tell that you were frustrated, and I’m interested in where that frustration came from.’ ‘Well, it’s because I need to concentrate.’ ‘Why do you need to concentrate?’ ‘Because it’s my responsibility to keep these people’s children safe.’ All of a sudden now, there’s no parent in the world that is upset with that bus driver because they’ve heard something underneath that was legitimate and shared. They also want their kids to be safe.
All the parents go home and give their kids some hell about being so loud and noisy on the bus. To me, that’s the power, if leaders can tap into it: really embracing the idea that understanding someone is different from agreeing with them. And we can put energy into understanding someone, even someone who is an opponent to us. We can put energy into understanding. We’re not implicitly also saying that we agree with what they did.
Hugh Ballou
That’s great advice. I’ve had similar situations where on the other side of it, it really bonded the relationship and actually put it on another level because I responded and didn’t react. I want to get even with them, but if I pause and wait and then ask questions and listen to the answers, people aren’t basically mean. We don’t need to assume they are. So, I want to talk about the Roy Group. In the Roy Group, the heart of your work, I believe, is the sovereignty of human spirit.
While I’m here, let’s talk about the Roy Group and how can people find it. It’s roygroup.net. For people watching, they can see it on the screen. People listening can’t. But tell us about Roy Group. What will people find when they go to roygroup.net?
Ian Chisholm
I think what we do a little differently is work with senior teams in organizations and invite them to consider: What would it look like if they earned the word ‘mentor’ together? In addition to leading well, working hard, and being good partners with each other, what happens in an organization when those senior six to eight people actually start earning the word ‘mentor’ together from the people who work in the organization? We know from doing this work for 22 years that succession happens more easily. Attraction of talent, retention of talent, engagement of that talent, all the good stuff, all of the things that will win the Super Bowl for your company happen when those top senior people act in a way that other people refer to them as mentors in the story of their life.
Leadership development becomes very easy in organizations where that top team has earned the word mentor together.
Hugh Ballou
And you make a distinction here, working with you to develop your next generation of leaders, and the asterisk says, by developing you as our next generation of mentors. So we’re replicating by creating mentors. It’s a fascinating website for those that are on the podcast. And it’s got little cute pictures on the side and you hover over and it opens up the menu. So, roygroup.net even has a contact place and I bet when people contact you, you do respond to them, right?
Ian Chisholm
You bet.
Hugh Ballou
Let’s talk about dignity. There’s the sovereignty of the human spirit, and there’s the dignity of people. And we don’t know how to make course corrections. And then we don’t do it. And then everybody thinks we’re a bad leader. The example I can give is as a conductor, I stop a rehearsal and say, ‘Trumpets, that’s too loud. Would you take it down one dynamic level? Let’s try it again.’ Well, they’re not offended. I didn’t attack them. They’re playing a loud instrument. They’re in the back. And so then we have another go at it.
There’s a way to do a course correction and protect the integrity and the spirit. So talk about how leaders nurture when things aren’t what they want.
Ian Chisholm
Well, I love the story you just told, Hugh, in that there was something bigger than all of us that we’re creating. And there’s a desire to make that the highest quality, the biggest impact possible. I think human teams are at their best when there’s some big promise in the air that this team has made to the world. Then there’s a reason for us giving each other feedback and holding each other to account because there’s something more important going on here than each of us. There was a period when I liked asking very accomplished people why they do what they do.
That expression, ‘sovereignty of the human spirit,’ came from one of those conversations. It was actually a conversation with my father-in-law, a gentleman named Sir John Daniel, who was the head of the Open University in the UK and is really one of the fathers of distance learning around the world. His answer was that he dedicated his life to creating organizations that would protect the sovereignty of the human spirit. It’s a very loaded word. Sovereignty literally means to reign over something. And so a lot of leaders, I think, have this sense of sovereignty.
They make their way through their weeks with this internal sense of sovereignty that what I’m doing is important. Yes, but what is it that you’re reigning over? Are you reigning over your team? Well, that’s pretty heavy language for my relationship with my team. I don’t reign over my team. You should meet some of them. Do you reign over your family? Well, you haven’t met Anne-Marie or the kids if you think that I reign over my family. So there’s this gap of, I sense that I’m sovereign, but I can’t identify to you what I’m sovereign over, what it is that I’m reigning over, until a very good friend of mine named Tim Galway mentioned or put forward the idea that perhaps what we reign over is the moments of our life.
Good things come into our court. We get to choose how we reign over that moment and how we steer it into something even greater. Bad things come into our court. We also get a chance to choose how we reign over those moments and take it to a place where we can start to build back. So now, in retrospect, I now know what my father-in-law was talking about. He wants people to realize that they have a lot of choice and responsibility over these choices that they make in the moments of their life.
And that’s where dignity comes from, when you get to make the choice.
Hugh Ballou
I love it. So, Quiet Champions: A Way Forward for Mentors in Turbulent Times. What inspired you to write that book?
Ian Chisholm
Hugh, you’ll know. You go through life, all the ups and downs, but there’s always like one thing that kind of captures your attention. For me, that’s always been mentorship. Always. And particularly, there was a time in my life when I left New York and landed a job on the Isle of Skye off the west coast of Scotland. It was a new leadership development center, and they were looking for somebody who had a background of working with young people from tough socioeconomic realities. That’s the work we were doing with the AMA.
I was 27 years old and landed my first CEO role. I was in way over my head, Hugh. It was bad. I was a hard worker, and I had some strong ideas about quality. And so I was prepared to put the work in, but I did not have the finesse or the practice to be a CEO. What I did have was a constellation of mentors that came out of the woodwork for me: community members, members of my board, and the chairman himself, who was the founder of this organization.
People across the UK and even around the world, some mentors traveled to the Isle of Skye to kind of help me make this story happen with our team. And I think in many ways writing Quiet Champions is nothing more than the acknowledgement section of a normal book, thanking all of those people and really trying to use my own advice to reflect and learn as much as I possibly can about mentorship from the examples of these people that really showed up for me in the biggest way.
Hugh Ballou
We’re about building high-performing cultures. As a conductor, that’s something I’ve done my whole life. In my work, fundability depends on people’s trust in our leadership and the culture we’ve created. That was my 19th book, so this is really consistent with things I’ve written. Are you game for a few rapid-fire questions as we end up here?
Ian Chisholm
Sure I am.
Hugh Ballou
One question every mentor should ask.
Ian Chisholm
What does the person in front of me need now?
Hugh Ballou
One sign a leader needs to pause.
Ian Chisholm
When their head feels full to the brim.
Hugh Ballou
One habit that makes reflection useful. Feedback after an important moment. One small act that strengthens dignity at work.
Ian Chisholm
Feedback after an important moment.
Hugh Ballou
Here’s a final question. You offer this paradox: You are the most important piece of work you will ever undertake, and it’s not about you. How do we live both truths?
Ian Chisholm
Fully. I think it’s very important that we take ourselves seriously. We are the most important piece of work we will ever undertake. That might sound self-centered. It is. Everything that we do is a chance to work on ourselves, to do it better, and to shape ourselves better. And when you think about the minute geological second that we are here for, it’s really not about us. We had better pass the torch incredibly well to the people that come after us. Both of those things are fundamentally true at the same time.
Hugh Ballou
Such great advice, Chiz. Thank you for helping us see leadership as a practice that we can choose every day. For our audience, choose one practice from today’s conversation. Try it in a real interaction and take time after to reflect on what you learned. Visit roygroup.net—R-O-Y group dot net—to learn more about the work of this fine gentleman in front of me and find his book. So thank you so much, Chiz, for being my guest today on The Nonprofit Exchange.
Ian Chisholm
No problem. Thanks very much, Hugh.








